IQM processor tests corrections to a quantum disorder model

Researchers at TU Dortmund University and the German Aerospace Center have achieved 89% relative energy accuracy by directly optimizing a 16-qubit system on an IQM superconducting quantum processor. The work demonstrates that information from strong-disorder renormalization-group methods can be used to build quantum circuits, with variational optimization then correcting approximations within the model. This approach extends a previously developed technique for one-dimensional systems to the more complex two-dimensional random transverse field Ising model. The results show that renormalization-group information translates to hardware-compatible circuits, while variational optimization improves accuracy beyond the initial approximation.

Two-Dimensional Ising Model & Emergent-Coupling-Based Ansatz (ECBA)

The structure of renormalization-group (RG) flows in two dimensions, which become increasingly complex, has been investigated through a novel application of variational quantum optimization. This adaptation allows the quantum state to move beyond the limitations of the RG approximation, capturing correlations the renormalization procedure alone would miss. Numerical simulations benchmarked the ansatz, comparing its performance against both the underlying RG approximation and a nearest-neighbor approach.

These tests assessed the ECBA’s ability to accurately represent ground states and its behavior as system size increased, demonstrating its potential for tackling quantum many-body systems with detailed connectivity. A 49-qubit system was evaluated using pre-optimized parameters on an IQM device, exploring the possibility of scaling the approach to larger, more complex simulations.

This level of optimization yielded a relative energy accuracy of 89%, indicating a significant improvement in correcting approximations within the quantum disorder model. The researchers highlight that the SDRG flow determines the circuit’s structure, while variational optimization refines the state, enabling corrections beyond the initial RG approximation. The paper illustrates how the variational neighborhood allows for optimization towards a more accurate energy minimum. The two-dimensional random transverse-field Ising ferromagnet was chosen as a particularly suitable system for this investigation due to the presence of an infinite-randomness critical point.

Unlike the one-dimensional random Heisenberg model, the geometry and interaction structure of the two-dimensional Ising model necessitate a reformulated ECBA construction. This reformulation accounts for the different patterns of emergent couplings that arise in the two-dimensional setting. The resulting ECBA uses parameterized Rzz gates, which can realize the identity, offering greater variational flexibility than fixed entangling gates like the CNOT.

Following the application of these entangling gates, an Rx rotation is applied to each qubit, followed by further entangling gates within clusters identified by the RG flow and another rotation on each qubit within those clusters. This approach, termed the emergent-coupling-based ansatz, uses a physically motivated circuit structure derived from the dominant effective couplings identified by the SDRG flow. The researchers believe this strategy holds promise for studying quantum many-body systems with complex connectivity, where accurate numerical simulations are often challenging.

“The successful application to two-dimensional systems demonstrates the potential of this approach,” the paper concludes, suggesting future work could explore larger systems, alternative disorder distributions and other quantum many-body models like the Ashkin-Teller model and the random Hubbard model. The team also envisions applying the ECBA ansatz to molecular electronic-structure problems, expanding its utility beyond condensed matter physics.

Strong-Disorder Renormalization-Group (SDRG) for Disordered Systems

The researchers achieved a relative energy accuracy of 89% on the 16-qubit system, while a 49-qubit system, investigated using pre-optimized parameters, yielded a relative energy accuracy of 97%. This precision stems from the combination of SDRG, which identifies dominant couplings in the low-energy physics of these systems, and variational optimization, which allows the quantum state to deviate from the initial RG approximation.

The team’s methodology builds upon an emergent-coupling-based ansatz (ECBA) initially developed for one-dimensional systems, extending it to the more complex realm of two-dimensional models. SDRG provides the foundational structure of the quantum circuit, while variational optimization introduces the flexibility needed to capture correlations beyond the initial RG description.

The researchers note that the RG flow does not represent an exact representation of the underlying many-body problem, as the decimation procedure involves approximations that discard information about quantum fluctuations. The success of this method extends beyond simply achieving high accuracy. It also highlights the potential for studying a broader class of disordered quantum systems amenable to SDRG analysis.

Numerical Validation of Two-Dimensional ECBA Accuracy

IQM’s superconducting quantum processor served as the platform for validating a new approach to modeling quantum disorder, achieving 89% relative energy accuracy on a 16-qubit system through full, on-hardware variational optimization. These simulations revealed that the ECBA consistently outperformed both alternatives across a range of system sizes and disorder strengths, with the exception of systems approaching a clean, non-disordered state where the nearest-neighbor ansatz performed comparably.

The team found that a high tolerance setting, specifically, a value of 0.99, improved results, though balancing tolerance with circuit complexity remains a key consideration for embedding the circuit onto quantum hardware. The threshold must be chosen with the limitations of the quantum hardware in mind.

16-Qubit IQM Processor Variational Optimization Results

Researchers implemented the complete workflow, encompassing circuit generation, parameter optimization and experimental measurement, to assess both the theoretical expressive power of the ansatz and its performance under realistic hardware conditions. The team investigated whether the variational optimization consistently lowered the energy relative to the initial renormalization-group approximation, effectively recovering correlations missed by the underlying flow. Experiments focused on a system of seven-by-seven spins on the IQM Emerald device, initially pre-optimizing parameters through classical simulations before estimating energy on the quantum processor, resulting in a 97% relative energy accuracy.

The hardware embeddings for both the four-by-four and seven-by-seven systems were visualized, revealing the mapping of logical qubit indices to physical qubits and the arrangement of gates within the RG clusters. Heatmaps of the Cij tensor network values for systems with L = 4 and L = 7 further detailed the optimization process.

These visualizations demonstrate how the emergent-coupling-based ansatz translates to shallow, hardware-compatible circuits while variational optimization enables corrections beyond the underlying RG approximation, even in two-dimensional systems. Expanding the scope of their investigation, the team also explored a 49-qubit system, using pre-optimized parameters to achieve a relative energy accuracy of 97%.

The experiments confirm the feasibility of this strategy on current superconducting quantum hardware, suggesting a pathway toward more accurate and efficient simulations of complex quantum phenomena. The work establishes that the ECBA approach is applicable to a broad class of disordered quantum systems which can be tackled using SDRG.

Energy Accuracy of 89% & 97% with Variational Optimization

IQM’s superconducting quantum processor enabled full variational optimization on a 16-qubit system, a step beyond relying on pre-calculated parameters and demonstrating a capacity for on-hardware refinement of quantum simulations. The researchers note that the variational optimization process modifies parameters of the RG-informed state, accounting for correlations and energy contributions neglected by the initial approximation. This combination of RG-derived structure and variational correction offers a pathway toward efficient simulations for disordered systems.

Analysis of the resulting quantum state revealed more than just energy level precision; the team also examined the correlation structure, finding that the initial state generated by the strong-disorder RG already encodes nontrivial long-range correlations. These correlations, extending over significant spatial distances near the quantum critical point, were further modified by the variational optimization process.

👉 More information
🗞 Variational Corrections to Strong-Disorder Renormalization in the Two-Dimensional Random Transverse Field Ising Model on Quantum Hardware
✍️ Alina Joch and Benedikt Fauseweh (Condensed Matter Theory, TU Dortmund University, Otto-Hahn-Straße 4, Dortmund, Germany)
🧠 ArXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.20932v1

Stay current

See today’s quantum computing news on Quantum Zeitgeist for the latest breakthroughs in qubits, hardware, algorithms, and industry deals.

Avatar of Rusty Flint

Rusty Flint

Rusty is a quantum science nerd. He's been into academic science all his life, but spent his formative years doing less academic things. Now he turns his attention to write about his passion, the quantum realm. He loves all things Quantum Physics especially. Rusty likes the more esoteric side of Quantum Computing and the Quantum world. Everything from Quantum Entanglement to Quantum Physics. Rusty thinks that we are in the 1950s quantum equivalent of the classical computing world. While other quantum journalists focus on IBM's latest chip or which startup just raised $50 million, Rusty's over here writing 3,000-word deep dives on whether quantum entanglement might explain why you sometimes think about someone right before they text you. (Spoiler: it doesn't, but the exploration is fascinating)

Latest Posts by Rusty Flint: