Researchers at Riverlane have developed a first-quantised phase estimation algorithm that significantly reduces the number of computational gates needed for quantum chemistry calculations. The work addresses a key limitation in current algorithms, which typically require a number of qubits that scales with the size of the molecule and often miss dynamical correlation effects.
For six molecules with up to 24 electrons, the new method required up to 16 times fewer Toffoli gates than second-quantised algorithms in the low-qubit regime, remaining cheaper up to approximately 1400 qubits. This approach, based on a non-convex sum-of-squares representation of the Hamiltonian and spectral-gap amplification, offers a path toward simulating realistic chemistry with limited quantum processing power.
First-Quantised SOSSA Algorithm for Molecular Energies
The first-quantised sum-of-squares spectral amplification (SOSSA) algorithm offers a potential advantage over standard second-quantised methods, particularly when dealing with systems where the number of orbitals significantly exceeds the number of electrons. This disparity is important for accurately modelling “dynamical correlation,” a phenomenon essential for realistic chemical simulations that is often missed in simplified calculations. Current quantum chemistry algorithms are frequently benchmarked using “active spaces” containing roughly the same number of orbitals as electrons.
However, capturing dynamical correlation demands several times more orbitals, even when employing compact atomic-orbital basis sets. The Riverlane team’s approach uses first quantisation, where the number of qubits needed to represent each electron grows logarithmically with the number of orbitals, offering a potential solution to this scaling challenge. The team directly compared the performance of their first-quantised algorithm against a second-quantised SOSSA algorithm, compiling both using identical techniques at the logical level.
This head-to-head comparison, detailed in their published work, reveals that the reduction in Toffoli gates could lead to a simpler circuit layout and potentially lower latency when accessing cold storage. For six molecules with 4 to 24 electrons in 5 to 14 times as many orbitals, the first-quantised method needs up to 16 times fewer Toffoli gates than the second-quantised algorithm in the low-qubit regime, where only a few hundred logical qubits are available.
It stays cheaper up to between several hundred and about 1400 qubits, and its smallest qubit count is 1.4 to 2 times lower than in second quantisation. In the low-qubit and low-filling regime, the algorithm is therefore well-suited for chemistry in orbital basis sets.
Low-Filling Regime Favors First Quantisation
This limitation in benchmarking creates a gap between theoretical tests and real-world chemical simulations, as capturing these correlations requires a substantial increase in computational resources. This means that as the number of orbitals increases, the qubit demand grows much more slowly in the first-quantised approach, potentially alleviating the pressure on quantum processor size.
Toffoli Gate Reduction with First Quantisation
This reduction in gate count is achieved even when the first-quantised method operates on its minimum qubit requirement, demonstrating an efficiency advantage in specific scenarios. For six molecules with 4 to 24 electrons in 5 to 14 times as many orbitals, the first-quantised method needs up to 16 times fewer Toffoli gates than the second-quantised algorithm in the low-qubit regime, where only a few hundred logical qubits are available.
It stays cheaper up to between several hundred and about 1400 qubits, and its smallest qubit count is 1.4 to 2 times lower than in second quantisation. In the low-qubit and low-filling regime, the algorithm is therefore well-suited for chemistry in orbital basis sets.
Comparison of First and Second Quantised SOSSA
For systems containing up to 24 electrons, the new first-quantised approach needs up to 16 times fewer Toffoli gates than the second-quantised algorithm in the low-qubit regime, where only a few hundred logical qubits are available. It stays cheaper up to between several hundred and about 1400 qubits, and its smallest qubit count is 1.4 to 2 times lower than in second quantisation. This performance is built on four key innovations: factorisation methods tailored for first quantisation, efficient block-encoding, a spectral-gap amplification protocol, and the synthesis of unitaries as multiplexed layers to minimise Toffoli gate requirements.
Logical Qubit Requirements for Quantum Chemistry
Capturing dynamical correlation, essential for accurately modeling real chemical systems, demands significantly more orbitals than electrons, even when using compact atomic-orbital basis sets, a challenge that Riverlane researchers directly addressed in their recent work. Most quantum chemistry algorithms are initially tested on “active spaces” where the number of orbitals roughly matches the number of electrons, a simplification that overlooks this important aspect of realistic chemical simulations.
This limitation highlights a need for algorithms capable of handling the increased complexity arising from accurately representing electron interactions. First quantisation, however, represents each electron with a number of qubits that increases logarithmically with orbital count, offering a potential advantage in the “low-filling regime” where orbitals outnumber electrons. The team’s work goes beyond theoretical comparisons, compiling both the first- and second-quantised algorithms using the same techniques at the logical level to assess practical performance.
Their results demonstrate a reduction in Toffoli gate counts for benchmark problems, a key metric for evaluating quantum circuit complexity. “Scaling quantum processors to thousands of logical qubits is a daunting engineering challenge,” said Aleksei V. Ivanov of Riverlane, “so developing algorithms that run with reduced qubit requirements is of particular importance.” Further work is needed to fully assess the physical qubit counts and runtime performance of the first-quantised method, but these initial findings offer a promising step toward more scalable quantum chemistry calculations.
Six-Molecule Benchmark: Electrons and Orbitals
Calculating molecular energies is expected to be an important application of quantum computers, but the most efficient algorithms to achieve this typically have significant space requirements. Scaling quantum processors to thousands of logical qubits is a daunting engineering challenge, so developing algorithms that run with reduced qubit requirements is of particular importance. most algorithms are benchmarked on active spaces with about as many orbitals as electrons, missing dynamical correlation which is necessary to describe real chemistry.
Capturing this correlation requires several times more orbitals than electrons, even in compact atomic-orbital basis sets. This low-filling regime favors first quantisation, where each electron is represented by a number of qubits that grows only logarithmically with the number of orbitals. Whether this approach translates into a practical advantage in orbital basis sets of realistic size, however, has been unclear.
Here, the researchers develop a first-quantised phase estimation algorithm for generic orbital basis sets, based on a non-convex sum-of-squares representation of the Hamiltonian and spectral-gap amplification. The researchers compare it with the second-quantised algorithm, compiling both with the same techniques at the logical level. For six molecules with 4 to 24 electrons in 5 to 14 times as many orbitals, their first-quantised method needs up to 16 times fewer Toffoli gates than the second-quantised algorithm in the low-qubit regime, where only a few hundred logical qubits are available.
It stays cheaper up to between several hundred and about 1400 qubits, and its smallest qubit count is 1.4 to 2 times lower than in second quantisation. In the low-qubit and low-filling regime, the algorithm is therefore well-suited for chemistry in orbital basis sets.
Spectral-Gap Amplification in First Quantisation
The new first-quantised approach reduces the number of Toffoli gates needed for quantum simulations, offering a potential advantage over second-quantised methods in specific scenarios, according to research detailed in a recent paper. For six molecules with 4 to 24 electrons in 5 to 14 times as many orbitals, the method needs up to 16 times fewer Toffoli gates than the second-quantised algorithm in the low-qubit regime, where only a few hundred logical qubits are available.
It stays cheaper up to between several hundred and about 1400 qubits, and its smallest qubit count is 1.4 to 2 times lower than in second quantisation. This performance is built on four key innovations: factorisation methods tailored for first quantisation, efficient block-encoding, a spectral-gap amplification protocol, and the synthesis of unitaries as multiplexed layers to minimise Toffoli gate requirements.
Researchers overcame limitations of convex representations by introducing a non-convex approach, alongside block-encoding strategies that allow for the direct application of spectral-gap amplification even with negative weights assigned to certain terms. In the low-qubit and low-filling regime, first quantisation is therefore well-suited for chemistry in orbital basis sets.
Block-Encoding Strategies for First-Quantised Systems
Employing a non-convex representation alongside new block-encoding strategies offers a reduction in computational cost for simulating quantum systems, particularly in the early stages of scaling. Researchers demonstrated that using a singular value decomposition (SVD) to reduce the cost of the first-quantised block-encoding requires fewer rotation angles than embedding a larger unitary directly, potentially saving computational resources.
For six molecules with 4 to 24 electrons in 5 to 14 times as many orbitals, the first-quantised method needs up to 16 times fewer Toffoli gates than the second-quantised algorithm in the low-qubit regime, where only a few hundred logical qubits are available. It stays cheaper up to between several hundred and about 1400 qubits, and its smallest qubit count is 1.4 to 2 times lower than in second quantisation. The work also builds on recent advancements in spectral-gap amplification, applying the protocol within the first-quantised framework using this non-convex representation.
Unlike a related study that used an analytical sum-of-squares representation specific to plane-wave bases, this approach aims for broader applicability across orbital basis sets. While second quantisation may become more efficient at higher qubit counts, the initial reduction in Toffoli gates offers a pathway to more manageable quantum simulations for systems with a limited number of qubits, a critical consideration as quantum processors continue to develop.
Advantage of First Quantisation at Low Qubit Counts
For systems with fewer than 40 electrons and 128 orbitals, a first-quantised approach to quantum chemistry calculations maintains a significant advantage in gate count, even as the number of available logical qubits increases. Analysis reveals that this advantage persists up to approximately 1400 logical qubits, though the margin narrows with scale. This resilience stems from how first quantisation handles the representation of electrons relative to the number of orbitals needed for accurate modelling of “dynamical correlation”.
The benefit of first quantisation becomes more pronounced as the size of the orbital basis set increases, with doubling the basis adding a comparatively small number of qubits to the first-quantised register. This contrasts with second quantisation, where doubling the basis set doubles the qubit requirement.
👉 More information
🗞 Quantum Simulation of First-Quantised Chemistry with a Sum-of-Squares Representation
✍️ Aleksei V. Ivanov, Christoph Sünderhauf, Jon Kunjummen, Nick S. Blunt and Róbert Izsák (Riverlane, Cambridge, UK)
🧠 ArXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.24885v1




See today’s quantum computing news on Quantum Zeitgeist for the latest breakthroughs in qubits, hardware, algorithms, and industry deals.
