The work demonstrates that depositing and then removing neon reduces energy loss caused by two-level systems, defects that limit the function of qubits, detectors and resonators. Analysis indicates this enhancement stems from the redistribution and removal of surface contaminants during the neon treatment, offering a non-destructive method for sensitive materials. These results demonstrate a simple approach for mitigating TLS losses in superconducting devices.

Solid Neon Enhances Superconducting Qubit Performance

Solid neon deposition and removal demonstrably improves the performance of superconducting devices by altering surface contaminants, a finding that offers a gentler alternative to harsh cleaning methods. NbTiN coplanar waveguide resonators exhibited enhanced performance after exposure to solid neon, suggesting a pathway to mitigate energy loss within qubits, detectors and resonators. This approach avoids aggressive cleaning processes that can damage sensitive materials, broadening its potential application beyond current limitations.

Analysis of resonator behavior revealed that the improvement stems from reduced dissipation caused by two-level systems, or TLSs, which are known sources of error in superconducting circuits. Atomic force microscopy of hexagonal boron nitride flakes confirmed this redistribution, visually demonstrating the removal of surface residues after neon exposure. Researchers found that the solid neon film effectively modifies surface contaminants without chemically reacting with the underlying material, offering an advantage for delicate quantum systems.

The team’s findings present an effective method for reducing TLS losses caused by fabrication residues, potentially applicable to a range of superconducting and semiconducting materials. This is particularly valuable for materials that cannot withstand traditional acid or plasma cleaning processes, expanding the toolkit for building high-performance quantum devices.

NbTiN Resonators Characterize TLS Loss Mechanisms

NbTiN resonators exhibited a marked increase in internal quality factor, or $Q_{i}$ , following exposure to and subsequent removal of a solid neon film, a result observed across two distinct resonator samples. Devices fabricated from NbTiN films on high-resistivity silicon substrates showed improvements averaging 4.3 times their initial $Q_{i}$ in one sample, and 2.4 times in another, demonstrating a consistent effect beyond initial measurement variation. This enhancement persisted even after the neon had fully evaporated, suggesting a lasting modification of the superconducting circuit’s properties.

The observed improvements were not limited to a single treatment; resonators that already showed increased $Q_{i}$ benefited further from an additional neon deposition, indicating a cumulative effect of the process. Analysis of temperature dependence revealed that the neon film does not reduce quasiparticle dissipation, a common source of energy loss in these systems, thereby isolating the mechanism of improvement to other loss pathways.

Measurements at 4 Kelvin, where thermal quasiparticle losses dominate, showed lower $Q_{i}$ values when the neon film was present compared to the bare chip, confirming this distinction. Comparing resonators that showed significant improvement with those that did not, researchers found that the $Q_{i}$ of improved resonators remained higher across a range of photon numbers at 20 millikelvin, a key indicator of reduced TLS influence.

This suggests that the neon deposition and evaporation process effectively alters the TLSs within the superconducting material. A second device, fabricated on a sapphire substrate with a 12-nanometer thick NbTiN film, mirrored these findings, reinforcing the reproducibility of the technique and its potential for broader application.

Two-Level Systems Limit Superconducting Circuit Quality

Analysing the power dependence of resonators following neon treatment revealed that the reduction in two-level system (TLS) dissipation was not simply a shift in the energy participation ratio or an effect of radiation-induced quasiparticles. The observed improvements in internal quality factor, $Q_{i}$ , stemmed from a decrease in TLS losses, a finding supported by detailed analysis of temperature and power dependence. Researchers demonstrated increases approaching a factor of two in the single photon regime and exceeding ten-fold at higher powers, indicating a substantial mitigation of error sources within the superconducting circuits.

The work builds on previous experiments using cryogenic noble-gas deposition to modify surface contaminants, but extends the understanding of the underlying mechanisms. Fitting transmission models to resonator data allowed extraction of both internal and coupling quality factors, $Q_{i}$ and $Q_{c}$ , respectively, providing a quantitative measure of performance enhancement.

The model incorporates parameters describing the density of TLSs and their coupling strength, alongside the relaxation and dephasing times of the TLSs themselves, offering a comprehensive framework for understanding the observed losses. The number of photons required to saturate the TLS systems, inversely proportional to the product of TLS relaxation and dephasing times, was also considered in the analysis.

This is significant because it implies that the process does not simply mask the TLSs but fundamentally alters the source of the dissipation. “By analysing the temperature and power dependence of these losses and how they change over the course of the neon depositions, we conclude that these improvements in $Q_{i}$ are the result of decreased losses from two-level systems,” the authors write.

Neon Treatment Redistributes Surface Contaminants

Atomic force microscopy revealed that solid neon doesn’t just mask surface contaminants on superconducting materials; it actively redistributes them, moving fabrication residues over micrometer distances. This redistribution, observed on hexagonal boron nitride flakes contaminated with polymer residues, creates larger clusters of debris while leaving substantial areas of the surface clear. The process offers a novel approach to mitigating two-level system (TLS) losses, a major obstacle to improving qubit performance.

Analysis of internal quality factors, or $Q_{i}$ , showed improvements in resonators following neon deposition and removal. This finding suggests the process isn’t simply a temporary masking of TLSs, but a lasting alteration of the surface contaminant landscape. The implications extend beyond niobium titanium nitride resonators, offering a gentler alternative to traditional cleaning methods. This is particularly valuable for sensitive materials susceptible to damage from harsher treatments.

Persistent Q_i Improvement After Neon Removal

Following neon removal, resonators in one device exhibited quality factors improving to 4.3 times their initial values, while those in a second device reached 2.4 times the original measurement, demonstrating a consistent, though variable, enhancement of superconducting performance. Detailed fitting procedures confirmed the improvement stemmed from reduced dissipation within two-level systems, specifically linked to the redistribution or removal of fabrication residues on the device surface, rather than alterations in dielectric participation or shielding from radiation.

The observed increases in quality factor were replicated across a second dilution refrigerator setup, bolstering the reliability of the findings and suggesting the effect is not specific to a single experimental environment. Analysis of hexagonal boron nitride flakes, contaminated prior to treatment, revealed that the solid neon process redistributed and removed surface residues, providing a visual confirmation of the proposed mechanism.

The temperature and power dependence of the improved resonators showed a stronger response across a wider range of microwave power after neon was removed and redeposited, a behavior not observed in control resonators that did not experience the same quality factor gains. Beyond one Kelvin, all resonators exhibited decreasing quality factors as quasiparticle-related losses became dominant, a phenomenon unaffected by the neon treatment. The research team’s approach offers a non-destructive alternative to conventional cleaning methods, such as acid or plasma etching, which can damage sensitive materials.

Atomic Force Microscopy Reveals Neon’s Residue Removal

Atomic force microscopy provided direct visualization of how solid neon alters surfaces at the nanoscale, revealing the relocation of contaminants on hexagonal boron nitride flakes. Before treatment, polymer residues from the exfoliation process were visible; subsequent imaging after neon exposure showed these residues coalescing into micrometer-scale clusters, leaving substantial portions of the surface clear. This redistribution supports the mechanism by which neon mitigates two-level system (TLS) losses within superconducting devices. These results, detailed in the supporting materials, suggest a variable but consistent enhancement of superconducting performance attributable to the neon treatment.

The team further enhanced Q_i in some resonators with an additional neon deposition, indicating that the process can be repeated to further refine device characteristics. “Atomic force microscopy images acquired before and after treatment reveal a redistribution of surface contaminants,” the paper states, “supporting the hypothesis that the neon process removes or displaces fabrication residues responsible for excess TLS loss.” This suggests that the effectiveness of the neon treatment is linked to the specific characteristics of the surface and the nature of the contaminants present. The research demonstrates a non-destructive approach to mitigating TLS losses, a critical challenge for sensitive materials that cannot withstand conventional cleaning methods.

👉 More information
🗞 Reducing TLS Losses in Superconducting Circuits Using Solid Neon
✍️ A. Palmer et al.
🧠 ArXiv: https://arxiv.org/html/2611.15021v1

More like this