New analysis finds limits to realism in quantum random access codes

Pedro R. Dieguez of the Federal University of Paraná has determined the minimum amount of deviation from classical reality needed for quantum random access codes to function effectively. The work quantifies “irrealism”, the extent to which a measurement outcome isn’t predetermined, and establishes an “irrealism frontier” representing the least amount required for each success probability in these codes, holding true in every dimension. The analysis reveals that for qubits, mutually unbiased decoders are not the most efficient option until a success probability of 0.833 is reached, a finding that challenges conventional wisdom in quantum communication.

Irrealism as a Criterion for Quantum Realism

The degree to which a measurement outcome deviates from being predetermined is directly linked to achieving a quantum advantage in communication, according to new work on quantum random access codes. Researchers have established a quantifiable measure of this deviation, termed “irrealism”, defined as the relative entropy distance from a quantum preparation to the closest one where a property is definitively real. This irrealism, calculated as an increase in entropy resulting from an unrevealed measurement, vanishes when a property is an element of reality.

This analysis reveals a fundamental trade-off between information delivery and the inherent irrealism of decoding observables; the information a code delivers about one observable is balanced by the irrealism of another, with performance and irrealism locked at the quantum optimum. Gibbs states of the decoding operator uniquely attain this frontier, meaning they represent the most efficient way to minimize irrealism for a given level of performance.

The researchers found that for prepare-and-measure codes, the required irrealism vanishes up to the classical value and becomes positive beyond it, indicating a clear quantum advantage. Entanglement-assisted codes, when using a qubit receiver, trusted decoders, and parity-dependent sender settings, exceed the performance of prepare-and-measure codes by the degree of realism-based nonlocality present in the shared quantum state. Specifically, a success probability exceeding 0.815 with rank-one projective sender measurements certifies a minimum level of realism-based nonlocality in the shared state.

The criterion used in this work focuses on whether a value is already encoded in the quantum preparation, rather than the existence of hidden-variable models. The paper states, “In the sense of the criterion, a quantum advantage in these codes requires decoding observables without definite values, and the information–reality exclusion gives this requirement the form of a complementarity.” This complementarity emphasises that gaining information about one observable necessitates accepting irrealism in another, a core tenet of quantum mechanics.

Irrealism Defined: Relative Entropy and Measurement

This irrealism comprises both local coherence within the decoding state and the correlations lost through an unrevealed measurement, applying to both prepare-and-measure and entanglement-assisted quantum codes. For prepare-and-measure codes, the irrealism frontier, the least total irrealism compatible with each success probability, is attained uniquely by Gibbs states of the decoding operator, a finding that holds true across all dimensions.

The work further demonstrates that the irrealism splits into a local component, reflecting the coherence of Bob’s reduced state, and a correlation component, representing the mutual information lost during an unrevealed measurement of the decoding observable. This challenges conventional wisdom in quantum communication, suggesting that alternative decoding strategies may offer advantages at lower success rates.

Irrealism’s Connection to Coherence and Quantum Discord

Irrealism, as a measure, extends beyond theoretical considerations and into experimental verification, having been demonstrated in nuclear magnetic resonance and photonic experiments. This quantification of deviation from classical predictability is not limited to single quantum systems; for bipartite preparations, irrealism accounts for both local coherence and the loss of correlations due to unrevealed measurements, establishing a lower bound defined by the sum of local coherence and quantum discord. The degree to which a measurement destroys correlations is therefore integral to understanding the system’s overall irrealism, with the quantum discord serving as a key component in its assessment.

Quantum Random Access Codes and Advantage

The minimum irrealism required for a quantum advantage in random access codes directly correlates with the success probability of decoding, according to work from the Federal University of Paraná. This means that specific quantum states consistently represent the most efficient decoding method across varying dimensional scales. Beyond this fundamental relationship, the analysis reveals a surprising threshold for prepare-and-measure codes using qubits. Below this point, alternative decoding strategies require less “irrealism,” challenging conventional wisdom regarding decoder selection.

Entanglement-assisted codes, however, demonstrate a more complex relationship between irrealism and success probability. A success probability exceeding 0. This connection is significant, as it links a specific communication performance threshold to a fundamental quantum property, offering a new method for verifying the presence of nonlocality.

Decoding Observables and Minimum Realism-Based Nonlocality

Specifically, the analysis reveals that the realism-based nonlocality of a shared quantum state can be certified by achieving a success probability exceeding 0.815 when using entanglement-assisted codes with rank-one projective sender measurements. This establishes a direct link between a quantifiable performance metric and a fundamental quantum property. The work quantifies how much “indefiniteness” is necessary for a given level of success in these communication protocols, focusing on the reality variation induced by measurements without altering the receiver’s local state.

This variation, termed realism-based nonlocality, is not merely a theoretical construct; it’s a measurable quantity tied to the contexts, the specific measurement settings, used by an optimal code. The analysis further demonstrates a symmetry in irrealism: “η_(B|A) = η_(A|B)”, meaning the reality conferred by an unrevealed measurement of one party on the other is equal in both directions.

The researchers emphasize that whether a decoding observable has a definite value depends on the entire experimental setup, including measurements on distant, unrevealed systems, and their work provides a quantifiable frontier for the minimum indefiniteness required for a given performance level.

Gibbs States Attain Irrealism Frontier in 2d→1 Codes

This finding establishes a precise mathematical connection between a code’s performance and its underlying quantum properties, a relationship previously understood only qualitatively. The analysis determines this minimum irrealism for each possible success probability, defining what is termed the “irrealism frontier”. Entanglement-assisted codes, however, require a higher degree of irrealism than their prepare-and-measure counterparts.

👉 More information
🗞 Quantifying the irrealism required by quantum random access codes
✍️ Pedro R. Dieguez (Department of Physics, Federal University of Paraná, Curitiba, Paraná, Brazil)
🧠 ArXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.26340v1

Stay current

See today’s quantum computing news on Quantum Zeitgeist for the latest breakthroughs in qubits, hardware, algorithms, and industry deals.

Avatar of Muhammad Rohail T.

Latest Posts by Muhammad Rohail T.: