Anomaly indices restrict phases in bosonic systems with symmetry groups

Internal symmetry is investigated. Anomaly indices of symmetry operators are constructed, along with their cocycle conditions and coboundary ambiguities. For generalised crystalline symmetries combining permutations of onsite Hilbert spaces with quantum cellular automata, anomaly indices take values in H3(BeΓ, You’re) and H4(BeΓ, Ur), where eΓ represents the total group of crystalline and internal symmetries, and the coefficient twist r accounts for spatial orientation reversal.

When crystalline symmetries act solely by permuting onsite Hilbert spaces, the anomaly classes restrict trivially to the spatial subgroup. These results offer a crystalline equivalence principle for bosonic anomalies at the microscopic level.

Spectral Sequence Differentials Resolve Anomalies in Bosonic Lattice Systems

Crystalline symmetries fundamentally constrain phases and low-energy dynamics within quantum many-body systems. A prime example is the Lieb, Schultz, Mattis (LSM) theorem: a spin chain with translation and internal symmetry cannot host a trivial symmetric gapped state when half-odd integer spin resides per unit cell; its higher-dimensional extensions reveal a general connection between lattice symmetry actions and necessary non-trivial low energy spectrum. Subsequent developments have established such constraints involving generic crystalline symmetries and diverse distributions of projective representations at onsite Hilbert spaces.

These advancements lead to complementary ways to formulate LSM theorems for more complex combinations of crystalline and internal symmetries using methods like lattice homotopy and operator algebraic approaches. Interpreting LSM constraints as symmetry anomalies has proven particularly fruitful.

Connections appear in Ref. between the LSM constraints and the symmetry action on anomalous surfaces of symmetry-protected topological (SPT) phases, while we develop continuum anomalies in Refs. In this description, microscopic lattice translation by a unit cell acts in the infrared as an internal symmetry, an emanant symmetry, and its corresponding LSM constraint is encoded within a mixed ’t Hooft anomaly involving that emanent symmetry alongside other inherited internal symmetries from the UV lattice model.

LSM type constraints involving generalised symmetries, including higher-form or non-invertible ones, have been discussed elsewhere regarding dynamical consequences. For free fermions, topological crystalline insulators and superconductors have been studied using band topology, K-theory, symmetry indicators, and topological quantum chemistry. Interacting crystalline phases admit bottom-up real-space constructions based on lower-dimensional building blocks and their junctions; generalised homology and the Atiyah, Hirzebruch spectral sequence organize consistency conditions among such constructions.

Explicit constructions of crystalline phases also test and refine the relation between classification of SPT phases with internal and crystalline symmetries. The crystalline equivalence principle formulated by Thorngren and Else provides a unifying framework: for crystalline topological phases on Euclidean space, it identifies the classification as equivalent to that for an Abstract symmetry group acting internally; mathematical formulations have been developed within generalised-homology descriptions of invertible phases. The equivalence principle receives support from microscopic probes like partial rotation operations.

This motivates a similar question regarding crystalline anomalies: if an infrared theory has Lorentz invariance, a crystalline operation acts in IR through spacetime Lorentz transformations combined with internal ones, making an internal-symmetry description natural, but general lattice systems need not possess such an IR limit with Lorentz symmetry. Moreover, whether general crystalline anomalies are described by inflow from bulk crystalline SPT phases or their classification coincides with that for crystalline SPTs remains unclear; establishing this requires direct microscopic characterisation alongside systematic analysis of dynamical consequences. Recent progress characterizes ’t Hooft anomalies at microscopic lattice models.

Microscopic anomalies involving translation have already been studied within quantum spin chains. These advances enable us to directly characterise crystalline anomalies using tensor product Hilbert spaces without relying on continuum descriptions or anomaly inflow from bulk crystalline SPT phases. This work develops a microscopic construction for bosonic systems in (1+1) and (2+1) dimensions combining both crystalline and finite unitary internal symmetry.

Explicit cocycle data are obtained for combined internal and crystalline symmetry actions, ambiguities identified to define cohomological data, and an obstruction to symmetric invertible states is established as a dynamical consequence. The internal symmetry group G is finite and unitary with operators U(g) preserving locality.

A spatial symmetry group Gsp acts on the lattice and may also act on the internal symmetry group G through conjugation via homomorphism φ: Gsp →Aut(G). If this action is nontrivial, the internal symmetry becomes modulated. This kernel expresses how a permutation action carries no ’t Hooft anomaly: every detected anomaly restricts to Gsp. In one spatial dimension the anomaly index consists of components ω0,3, ω1,2 and ω2,1; in two dimensions it comprises ω0,4, ω1,3, ω2,2 and ω3,1.

Ambiguities among these indices give coboundary transformations defined by that same double complex; their collection gives cohomology, a single invariant. These relations define an extension 1 −→G −→Γ p −→Gsp −→1. For extensions treated here, the anomaly index takes values in H3(BeΓ, You’re) and H4(BeΓ, Ur), where Γ represents the total group of crystalline and internal symmetries, and r accounts for spatial orientation reversal.

When crystalline symmetries act solely by permuting onsite Hilbert spaces, anomaly classes trivially restrict to the spatial subgroup. This conclusion concerns combined crystalline and finite unitary internal symmetry actions; onsite internal symmetries are not required but may participate in modulated anomalies.

Equations establish microscopic crystalline equivalence for bosonic anomalies with the same cohomological description as corresponding continuum versions. This statement arises from lattice symmetry operators without assuming specific infrared theory properties. The strategy builds on an Else, Nayak approach extended into two dimensions and compares with microscopic formulas in (1+1)D translationally symmetric spin chains, providing explicit formulas for each component of anomaly indices ωp,q in one and two spatial dimensions, generalizing a microscopic formula for anomalies.

Our setup incorporates modulated symmetries where crystalline symmetry acts on internal symmetry through permutations alongside orientation-reversing actions. Anomaly indices are constructed for combined internal and crystalline symmetry; these take values in H3(Bwidetilde Γ,Ur) and H4(Bwidetilde Γ,Ur). Spectral sequence differentials may trivialize candidate LSM anomaly indicators. These developments concern microscopic characterisation of crystalline symmetry anomalies in bosonic lattice systems in (1+1) and (2+1) dimensions with combined crystalline and finite unitary internal symmetry.

This work constructs anomaly indices for symmetry operators and derives their cocycle conditions and coboundary ambiguities. For generalised crystalline symmetries combining permutations of onsite Hilbert spaces with quantum cellular automata, the indices take values in H3(BeΓ, You’re) and H4(BeΓ, Ur), where eΓ represents the total group of crystalline and internal symmetries, and r accounts for spatial orientation reversal.

When crystalline symmetries only permute local Hilbert spaces, anomaly classes trivially restrict to the spatial subgroup. These results establish a crystalline equivalence principle for bosonic anomalies at the microscopic level without assuming continuum descriptions or Lorentz invariance; a nontrivial index obstructs any symmetric invertible phase.

Symmetry-based Constraints on Material Stability Remain Incomplete But Powerful

Researchers at University of Tokyo have demonstrated that spectral sequence differentials can now trivialize candidate Lieb, Schultz, Mattis anomaly indices, a feat previously impossible. They achieved this by characterising anomalies within (1+1) and (2+1)-dimensional systems combining crystal structure with intrinsic quantum properties. The team’s work defines new anomaly indices valued in mathematical spaces H3(Bwidetilde Γ,Ur) and H4(Bwidetilde Γ,Ur), effectively providing a microscopic understanding of how symmetry violations manifest in these bosonic lattice systems without relying on assumptions about continuous space or Lorentz invariance.

Symmetry-based Constraints on Material Stability Remain Incomplete But Powerful

While this work elegantly demonstrates how crystalline symmetries constrain possible quantum states in materials, effectively ruling out certain stable configurations based on their inherent atomic arrangement, a lingering question concerns completeness. The researchers acknowledge they’ve proven these anomaly indices obstruct specific phases but haven’t yet shown they are sufficient to fully catalogue all possibilities; more hidden arrangements may exist within those complex mathematical spaces than currently revealed. Despite the possibility of further hidden configurations, this work represents significant progress understanding material stability.

The team has established powerful constraints: inherent symmetries demonstrably rule out certain arrangements of atoms and this ‘crystalline equivalence principle’, linking symmetry to allowed phases offers a new perspective through which physicists can predict and design materials with specific quantum properties regardless any remaining unknowns. This rigorous framework establishes strong constraints on material stability, symmetries demonstrably rule out certain atomic arrangements reflecting the crystalline equivalence principle at work. The findings will likely fuel new materials discovery in coming decade allowing physicists begin designing quantum systems unprecedented control over their properties.

This research characterized anomalies, symmetry violations, in bosonic lattice systems across one- and two-dimensional spaces by defining anomaly indices valued in mathematical spaces H3 and H4. These results demonstrate that non-trivial total anomaly indices prevent the existence of symmetric invertible phases within these systems; effectively ruling out specific stable configurations based on inherent symmetry.

This establishes a “crystalline equivalence principle” offering a microscopic understanding of how symmetries constrain possible material states without relying on assumptions about continuous space or Lorentz invariance, reproducing known constraints like LSM and SPT, LSM. The authors note further work is needed to fully catalogue all possibilities within those complex mathematical spaces.

👉 More information
🗞 Crystalline Equivalence Principle for Anomalies
✍️ Ching-Yu Yao and Ryohei Kobayashi (University of Tokyo)
🧠 ArXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.15857

Stay current

See today’s quantum computing news on Quantum Zeitgeist for the latest breakthroughs in qubits, hardware, algorithms, and industry deals.

Avatar of Muhammad Rohail T.

Latest Posts by Muhammad Rohail T.: