Ice shrinks when heated, and quantum effects explain why, say scientists

Cubic ice Ic, created by carefully degassing C2 hydrogen hydrate, defies conventional physics by shrinking when heated. Researchers led by Loan Renaud of Laboratoire de physique de L’École normale supérieure de Paris report neutron diffraction measurements showing this unique ice form reaches its maximum density near 70 K, a value remarkably close to that of common hexagonal ice Ih despite a different structure.

This suggests negative thermal expansion in ice isn’t tied to a specific arrangement of water molecules, but instead stems from the behavior of its hydrogen-bond network. The team’s path-integral molecular dynamics simulations confirm the anomaly only when accounting for nuclear quantum effects, establishing the phenomenon as a collective quantum effect governed by nuclear statistics and the dynamics of the hydrogen-bond network.

Cubic Ice Ic Demonstrates Negative Thermal Expansion

Neutron-derived displacement parameters independently confirmed a strongly enhanced transverse displacement of protons, while phonon calculations identified low-frequency transverse modes exhibiting the most negative Grüneisen parameters. These parameters indicate that the frequency of these vibrational modes increases with volume, contributing to the overall contraction of the ice structure when heated. Analysis of the harmonic phonon dispersion, computed using the MB-pol interatomic potential, revealed that while intramolecular stretching and bending modes show only marginally negative Grüneisen parameters, they are not the primary drivers of the contractive response.

The study focused on stacking-disorder-free cubic ice Ic, created through the topotactic degassing of C2 hydrogen hydrate, a method that allowed for precise control over the ice structure. The researchers mapped mode-resolved Grüneisen parameters onto the harmonic phonon dispersion to pinpoint the specific modes responsible for the negative thermal expansion.

Slices of the interpolated potential energy surface in the molecular local frame, both for classical and quantum environments, further illuminated the underlying mechanisms driving this unusual behavior. The density maximum observed at 70 K coincides, within the temperature resolution, with maximal anisotropy of the proton quantum distribution, indicating a strong link between the quantum behavior of protons and the macroscopic thermal expansion properties of the ice.

The team’s work builds on the understanding that negative thermal expansion occurs in open framework materials when low-lying vibrational modes with negative Grüneisen parameters become thermally populated. The findings offer new insight into the behavior of water ice under extreme conditions and could have implications for materials science and their understanding of the properties of other hydrogen-bonded materials.

Path-Integral Simulations Reveal Quantum Effects in Ice

Path-integral molecular dynamics simulations confirmed a surprising correspondence between two ice structures despite differing arrangements of water molecules. This similarity, observed across the cryogenic stability range, indicates that negative thermal expansion in ice isn’t dictated by a specific stacking sequence, but instead originates from the shared open tetrahedral hydrogen-bond network present in both forms.

Classical molecular dynamics simulations, which do not account for these quantum effects, predicted a monotonically increasing density upon cooling for both ice polymorphs. Above 150 K, path-integral molecular dynamics also yielded a systematically higher density than classical molecular dynamics, consistent with previous quantum harmonic approximation and path-integral molecular dynamics studies.

The team’s work achieved a maximum relative error of approximately 0.2% in matching experimental data, an order of magnitude smaller than previous estimates using the q-TIP4P/f potential. “Simulations with the MB-pol potential quantitatively reproduce the experimental anomaly only when nuclear quantum effects are included,” the researchers state in their report, highlighting the critical role of quantum mechanics in understanding this phenomenon.

The ability to accurately model these effects relies on the ring-polymer representation within the path-integral framework, which effectively accounts for the wave-like nature of atomic nuclei. This approach contrasts with classical simulations that treat atoms as point-like particles, neglecting their quantum behavior.

MB-pol Potential Accurately Models Hydrogen-Bond Dynamics

Simulations using the MB-pol interatomic potential accurately reproduced this anomaly only when incorporating nuclear quantum effects, demonstrating the importance of quantum mechanics in modeling ice behavior. These low-frequency modes, important for understanding the contraction upon heating, are selectively weighted by Bose-Einstein statistics at lower temperatures.

The research team constructed a model of a single proton embedded within the Ic crystal environment, solving for its behavior at varying oxygen-oxygen distances to isolate the proton’s contribution to the effective lattice potential. This approach allowed them to differentiate between classical and quantum embeddings, revealing how quantum fluctuations influence the overall lattice response.

The effective oxygen-oxygen interatomic potential, dictating cell volume expansion, is demonstrably renormalized by this non-trivial proton dynamics. The study found that classical molecular dynamics fails to reproduce the negative thermal expansion despite employing the same MB-pol potential, because it relies on equipartition rather than Bose-Einstein statistics. “Negative Grüneisen parameters are a necessary but not sufficient condition to explain the emergence of NTE; the quantum-statistical weighting of the different phonon branches is essential,” the researchers state.

The team’s work builds on the recent availability of stacking-disorder-free ice Ic, created in 2020 through a C2-hydrate route that maintains sufficient stability throughout the temperature range containing the NTE anomaly. Prior to this, nominally cubic ice often contained stacking disorder, which perturbed lattice dynamics and complicated analysis.

By combining neutron powder diffraction with both classical and path-integral molecular dynamics using the MB-pol potential, the researchers aimed to determine how NTE depends on crystal topology and uncover its microscopic origin. The proton zero-point energy, as a function of the oxygen-oxygen distance, differs significantly between the classical and quantum models, highlighting the impact of quantum effects on the potential energy surface.

The study’s detailed analysis of phonon behavior demonstrates that the selective low-temperature weighting of negative-γ branches is critical for accurately modeling NTE, a nuance absent in classical simulations. This work provides a more complete picture of how quantum effects influence macroscopic properties in ice.

Neutron Diffraction Confirms Anisotropic Proton Displacement

Neutron diffraction measurements reveal a pronounced enhancement of transverse proton displacement within the structure of cubic ice Ic, a finding that bolsters the understanding of its unusual thermal behavior. This anisotropic movement, where protons vibrate more strongly perpendicular to the oxygen-hydrogen bond, coincides with the density maximum observed around 70 K and is a key component in explaining why this ice form shrinks when heated.

The ability to study this effect directly stems from the recent creation of stacking-disorder-free ice Ic, produced by topotactic degassing of C2 hydrogen hydrate. Prior to 2020, the presence of stacking disorder in nominally cubic ice interfered with accurate measurements of lattice dynamics, obscuring the underlying physics. The team’s method yields a cubic phase stable enough to analyze across the cryogenic range where negative thermal expansion occurs, allowing for detailed neutron scattering experiments.

These experiments, conducted at the D20 neutron diffractometer, confirmed the disappearance of diffuse scattering from disordered guest molecules, indicating a successful transformation to the pure cubic form. Analysis of neutron diffraction patterns, combined with path-integral molecular dynamics simulations using the MB-pol potential, revealed a strong correlation between the anisotropic proton distribution and the macroscopic negative thermal expansion. Specifically, the gyration radius, a measure of proton quantum distribution, is systematically larger for H2O than D2O at all temperatures, consistent with the lighter mass of hydrogen.

The observed transverse displacement amplitude of approximately 0.137 Å, derived from the neutron data, aligns closely with values obtained from path-integral molecular dynamics. This agreement, while qualitative due to the differing methods of measurement, provides independent validation of the theoretical model.

The team’s work also identifies low-frequency transverse modes with the most negative Grüneisen parameters, indicating that these vibrational modes are particularly sensitive to temperature changes and contribute significantly to the overall contraction upon heating. “Our observation supports a direct link between the anisotropic proton quantum distribution and the macroscopic NTE,” the researchers state.

The close similarity in density maxima between ice Ic and hexagonal ice Ih, despite their different stacking sequences, emphasises that negative thermal expansion is an intrinsic property of the hydrogen-bonded network itself. The research connects the anisotropic quantum distribution of protons, the low-frequency vibrational modes and the quantum-statistical weighting of these modes in the vibrational free energy.

Topotactic Degassing Creates Stacking-Disorder-Free Ice Ic

The creation of stacking-disorder-free cubic ice Ic relies on a specific preparation method: topotactic degassing of C2 hydrogen hydrate, a process that ensures a stable cubic structure throughout the temperature range where negative thermal expansion (NTE) occurs. This technique, detailed by Komatsu and colleagues, is critical because previous attempts to create cubic ice often resulted in samples containing stacking disorder, hexagonal faults that disrupted the lattice dynamics and obscured the true behavior of the material.

The ability to produce a consistently pure cubic phase allowed for detailed investigation into the origins of NTE, a phenomenon where a substance shrinks when heated, defying conventional physics. Analysis of the resulting ice Ic using neutron powder diffraction confirmed the complete removal of guest D2 molecules from the C2 hydrogen hydrate, evidenced by the disappearance of associated diffuse scattering patterns and the emergence of a strong diffraction peak characteristic of the cubic structure.

Rietveld refinement of the neutron data revealed a negligible D2 occupancy at the guest site, less than 0.00(4), and identified minor amounts of residual ice VIII, brucite, and unreacted MgD2, none of which interfered with the analysis of the primary cubic phase. This meticulous characterization established the purity of the sample, a prerequisite for accurately studying its unusual thermal properties. Researchers found that the network’s response to temperature changes, rather than localized bond behavior, drives the contraction.

This framework also explains why denser ice polymorphs typically do not exhibit comparable NTE, as compression stiffens the low-frequency vibrational modes within their networks and alters proton delocalization. Path-integral molecular dynamics (PIMD) simulations, using the MB-pol interatomic potential, were essential in confirming the experimental findings and elucidating the microscopic origins of NTE.

The simulations highlight the importance of treating the crystal environment as an ensemble of quantum particles, revealing that the NTE is a collective nuclear quantum response of the hydrogen-bond network. The research positions stacking-disorder-free ice Ic as a valuable reference material for understanding quantum-driven thermodynamic anomalies in other open tetrahedral networks, offering a chemically transparent system for investigating these complex phenomena.

The ability to isolate and study this unusual form of ice provides a minimal model for exploring the interplay between quantum mechanics and macroscopic properties, potentially informing the design of new materials with tailored thermal behavior.

👉 More information
🗞 Negative thermal expansion in cubic ice: A collective quantum effect of the hydrogen-bond network
✍️ Loan Renaud, Tomasz Poreba, Richard Gaal, A. Marco Saitta, Michele Casula and Livia Eleonora Bove
🧠 DOI: http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/2jx4-c8w1

Stay current

See today’s quantum computing news on Quantum Zeitgeist for the latest breakthroughs in qubits, hardware, algorithms, and industry deals.

Avatar of Rusty Flint

Rusty Flint

Rusty is a quantum science nerd. He's been into academic science all his life, but spent his formative years doing less academic things. Now he turns his attention to write about his passion, the quantum realm. He loves all things Quantum Physics especially. Rusty likes the more esoteric side of Quantum Computing and the Quantum world. Everything from Quantum Entanglement to Quantum Physics. Rusty thinks that we are in the 1950s quantum equivalent of the classical computing world. While other quantum journalists focus on IBM's latest chip or which startup just raised $50 million, Rusty's over here writing 3,000-word deep dives on whether quantum entanglement might explain why you sometimes think about someone right before they text you. (Spoiler: it doesn't, but the exploration is fascinating)

Latest Posts by Rusty Flint: