Daniele Cenni of the University of Florence has developed a local hidden-variable model that reproduces quantum-like correlations by deliberately violating a standard rule in Bell-type experiments, the “fair-sampling assumption” required by the CHSH inequality. The work introduces a sigmoid-based threshold mechanism to model linear polarization measurements, demonstrating that this construction produces CHSH-type violations only within a postselected sample of detected particles.
This model operates outside the assumptions of both the CHSH inequality and Mermin’s 82. 8% efficiency bound, while remaining compatible with loophole-free Bell experiments that specifically address the detection loophole exploited here. The results characterize how a local, setting-dependent postselection mechanism shapes Bell-test statistics across a range of entanglement parameters.
Local Hidden-Variable Model for Postselected EPR Correlations
Daniele Cenni of SIAF, University of Florence, developed the model, which uses a sigmoid-based threshold mechanism to simulate linear polarization measurements and bypass standard constraints on local realism. This construction allows for CHSH-type violations, but only within the subset of detected events selected after the measurements, rather than across the entire sample. The model’s ability to mimic quantum behavior hinges on a setting-dependent detection efficiency, meaning the probability of detecting a photon changes based on the measurement settings.
This approach circumvents the 82. Unlike those experiments, this model does not attempt to explain quantum correlations, but rather to reproduce them through a strictly local mechanism. The model’s behavior is characterized by a hidden-variable distribution, N(θ,σ_G^2), with defining the spread of the distribution. Alternative parametrizations of could yield different results and remain an area for future exploration.
While the CH-Eberhard analysis remained qualitatively unchanged, the shift demonstrates that even a simple memory component within the model can measurably alter its behavior. “The CHSH violations observed in the postselected sample derive from the model’s hidden-variable-dependent detection, with setting-dependent efficiency for |r| < 1,” the paper states, emphasizing the role of this setting-dependent detection in generating the observed correlations.
8% efficiency bound. This construction deliberately violates the “fair-sampling assumption” central to the CHSH inequality, yet still mimics quantum behavior within the selected data subset. Researchers demonstrated that the CH-Eberhard analysis, applied in a configuration with one detector per side, consistently yields J < 0 across the entire range of entanglement parameters, confirming the model’s strictly local nature. Detailed calculations reveal how the Bell parameter S changes with varying entanglement parameters.
These values are calculated alongside metrics like joint detection efficiency, single detection efficiencies, and root mean squared error, providing a comprehensive picture of the model’s performance. This work is not in conflict with loophole-free Bell experiments, which are designed to close the detection loophole that this model deliberately exploits, and offers a new perspective on the boundaries of local realism.
CH-Eberhard Analysis Confirms Strict Locality (J 0)
This result stems from a binary coarse-graining of simulation outcomes, mapping three-valued detection events to a two-valued system for the CH-Eberhard analysis. Specifically, a single click in the monitored channel registers as positive, while any other outcome, a click in the unmonitored channel, no click, or a double-click, is categorized as zero.
Despite this shift, the qualitative behavior of the CH-Eberhard analysis remains unchanged under the tested conditions, indicating that the addition of memory does not fundamentally alter the model’s ability to produce local, albeit correlated, outcomes. The quantum joint detection probabilities for |⟩, used as input to the CH-Eberhard analysis, are derived directly from the Born rule, ensuring consistency with quantum mechanical predictions.
Setting-Dependent Detection Reproduces Quantum-Like Correlations
This approach directly addresses whether locally-defined quantum-like correlations, evaluated using only a hidden variable and polarizer angle, can generate postselection dependent on the detection sample. This violation, however, does not invalidate the model’s results, as the standard CHSH inequality is not applicable under these conditions. Figures detailing the Bell parameter S and root mean squared error (RMSE) between model and quantum mechanical correlations illustrate the relationship between r and the states |⟩ and |⟩.
Data reported in accompanying tables show that the model’s performance is visually summarized across the tested range of parameters. Joint detection efficiency is setting-dependent for the fixed-threshold model, as detailed in supplementary materials. The model does not attempt to provide a physical explanation for the correlations observed in loophole-free Bell experiments, but rather demonstrates a local construction capable of reproducing quantum-like behavior under specific conditions.
|Φ_r⟩ and |Ψ_r⟩ States Characterize Entanglement Parameters
The threshold used in the model adjusts to the entanglement strength, denoted as |r|, with states | + ⟩ and |⟩ exhibiting a relationship where a change in sign of ‘r’ only affects the correlation sign, handled separately by a parameter within the sigmoid detection probabilities. A paired comparison shows that a local adaptive-threshold mechanism produces a systematic and reproducible shift in the CH-Eberhard parameter J relative to the fixed-threshold model, while leaving the CH-Eberhard analysis qualitatively unchanged under the tested conditions.
Adaptive Thresholds Introduce One-Sided Memory Effects
An adaptive-threshold mechanism alters the predicted outcome of Bell-type experiments, demonstrating a systematic shift in a key parameter even without communication between measurement stations. Researchers investigated whether implementing a one-sided memory, where each detector independently records its measurement history, would measurably change the behavior of a local hidden-variable model designed to mimic quantum correlations.
This exploration focused on the CH-Eberhard parameter J, a value used to assess the degree of locality in a system, and compared results to a fixed-threshold model lacking such memory. The researchers found that while the adaptive threshold alters the value of J, the overall qualitative behavior, specifically, maintaining J < 0 throughout the tested range, remains consistent with a strictly local model.
Postselection Expands Local Correlation Polytope (Branciard)
The implementation of one-sided memory within a local hidden-variable model demonstrably alters the predicted outcomes of Bell-type experiments, shifting the CH-Eberhard parameter J relative to a fixed-threshold model. This adaptive-threshold mechanism, which operates on local information only, introduces a systematic and reproducible change in the model’s behavior without fundamentally altering its qualitative predictions. The work characterizes how closely this local construction reproduces quantum-like correlations in the postselected detected sample.
👉 More information
🗞 On a local hidden-variable model for postselected EPR correlations
✍️ Daniele Cenni (SIAF, University of Florence, Firenze, Italy)
🧠 ArXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.24534v1




See today’s quantum computing news on Quantum Zeitgeist for the latest breakthroughs in qubits, hardware, algorithms, and industry deals.
