Equations of motion model quantum currents in Cooper pair splitters

Riya Baruah of Aalto University and colleagues have demonstrated that hierarchical equations of motion (HEOM) accurately model electric currents in Cooper pair splitters when experiments involve finite voltage or temperature differences, conditions where simpler theoretical descriptions fail. The researchers employed HEOM to capture the combined effects of strong coupling and interactions within these devices, achieving quantitative agreement with measured currents.

This work also accounts for an experimentally observed thermoelectric effect in Cooper pair splitters, showing the framework can model both energy and charge transport. The results reveal HEOM as a valuable tool for understanding quantum transport in these and related hybrid devices.

Hierarchical Equations of Motion Model Quantum Currents

Hierarchical equations of motion (HEOM) successfully reproduce analytical results derived from Markovian Lindblad equations when applied to Cooper pair splitters operating under large voltage conditions, establishing a connection between these distinct theoretical frameworks. This convergence allows for validation of the more complex HEOM approach against established methods in a specific, well-defined regime. The ability to reduce to known analytical solutions provides a benchmark for assessing the accuracy of HEOM calculations in more challenging scenarios.

This is particularly relevant as recent experiments have increasingly focused on these non-equilibrium conditions, demanding theoretical tools capable of accurately capturing the resulting complexities. This capability stems from the HEOM’s capacity to capture non-perturbative interactions, which are essential for understanding how energy and charge are coupled in these hybrid devices.

The theoretical approach begins with an exact formal expression for the time-evolved density matrix of the quantum dots, derived using the fermionic influence functional, and then builds toward the HEOM implementation. Spectral densities of the leads are defined as Lorentzian, centered around the chemical potential of the leads, allowing for a subtle representation of the electronic environment.

The study details a model of a Cooper pair splitter consisting of two quantum dots tunnel-coupled to a superconductor and normal-state electrodes, providing a clear geometric foundation for the calculations. Researchers computed electric currents as functions of the level positions of the splitter for various voltage and temperature configurations, revealing how these parameters influence device performance.

The resulting currents were then compared against experimental measurements, confirming the quantitative accuracy of the HEOM approach in realistic operating conditions. “With large voltages, our approach yields analytical results based on Markovian Lindblad master equations, which provide a useful benchmark for the numerical calculations,” the authors state.

The work investigates charge transport beyond the limitations of weak-coupling and Markovian assumptions, offering a more robust and versatile tool for analyzing quantum transport in Cooper pair splitters and similar hybrid devices. By accurately capturing the interplay of strong coupling, nonperturbative interactions and finite biases, HEOM provides a framework for understanding the behavior of these systems in a wider range of experimental scenarios.

Cooper Pair Splitter Device Geometry and Current Mechanisms

Calculations of electric current within a Cooper pair splitter reveal a resonance confined to a specific range of quantum dot level positions, diminishing rapidly when those levels fall outside the chemical potential boundaries of the electrodes. This behavior contrasts with broader current flow observed in systems modeled with simpler methods, and highlights the importance of accounting for interactions beyond weak-coupling approximations.

The simulations, mirroring experimental setups, show a smooth transition between conducting and nonconducting regions as temperature increases, broadening the transport window. The study details how the current’s concentration around the resonance condition changes depending on the device’s geometry and applied voltages, with the left and right electrodes functioning as drains when a voltage is applied.

Visualizations of these current patterns, generated by the HEOM calculations, demonstrate the distinct current profiles for each configuration, and show how the current is affected by the strength of Coulomb interactions within the quantum dots. “When either quantum dot level is moved outside the transport window set by the chemical potentials, the current decreases rapidly,” the paper notes, describing the sensitivity of the system.

These effects arise from the interplay of superconducting correlations, energy filtering by the quantum dots and nonlocal transport processes. The calculations reveal that the thermoelectric current generated by a temperature difference between the normal-state leads depends on both the quantum dot levels and the temperature gradient, with elastic cotunneling and nonlocal Cooper pair splitting contributing differently depending on device alignment.

The team used HEOM to investigate these thermoelectric effects, analyzing how the resulting currents depend on the quantum dot levels and the temperatures of the leads. The HEOM approach’s ability to accurately model these effects is particularly significant given the limitations of Markovian descriptions when dealing with finite voltage or temperature differences. While simplified models can provide analytical results under certain conditions, they struggle to capture the complex interplay of factors present in real-world experiments.

The team’s simulations show particle current induced by a temperature difference between the two normal-state leads, with no applied voltage, and illustrate how the current varies with the parameters of the system. By accurately capturing these complex interactions, the HEOM approach offers a valuable tool for understanding and optimizing the performance of Cooper pair splitter devices.

Elastic Cotunneling and Cooper Pair Splitting Currents

The interplay between elastic cotunneling and Cooper pair splitting manifests as distinct resonance patterns in electric currents flowing through quantum dot systems. Conversely, when a large voltage is applied, a resonance emerges along the anti-diagonal, signifying Cooper pair splitting as the dominant mechanism. The maximum absolute current resulting from elastic cotunneling reaches 4Γκ^2/(3(ℏΓ)^2 + 6κ^2), while Cooper pair splitting achieves a maximum value of 2Γγ^2/((ℏΓ)^2 + 4γ^2).

By analyzing the measured currents, the ratio of the amplitude for Cooper pair splitting to the tunneling rate, γ/(ℏΓ) and the ratio of the amplitude for elastic cotunneling to the tunneling rate, κ/(ℏΓ), can be established. While analytical expressions derived from earlier models align well with experimental data obtained under high voltage biases, they struggle to accurately predict current behavior when quantum dot levels fall outside the established transport window. This limitation arises because the simplified models do not fully account for the constraints imposed by the chemical potentials of the leads.

Thermoelectric Effects in Cooper Pair Splitters via HEOM

The calculations demonstrate how finite voltage and temperature differences, alongside interactions and broadening effects, impact charge transport in these devices, offering a more complete picture than earlier approaches. This capability extends beyond merely matching current values. It accurately models the suppression of transport when quantum dot levels shift outside the device’s operational range. The research reveals that non-Markovian effects, stemming from the structure of the reservoirs connected to the splitter, significantly influence transport characteristics.

Specifically, the positions of current resonances tied to both elastic cotunneling and Cooper pair splitting are affected, though the underlying conditions defining these processes remain consistent. This subtle understanding allows for a more precise prediction of device behavior under varying conditions.

Researchers suggest that HEOM could be applied to explore spin-resolved transport and entanglement generation in devices supporting both singlet and triplet Cooper-pair splitting, as demonstrated in recent experiments. The framework could be used to model the effects of time-dependent driving protocols, such as gate-voltage modulation and pumping schemes, where non-Markovian effects are expected to play an important role.

“Our calculations reproduce key features observed in recent experiments on Cooper pair splitters, including thermoelectric transport induced by temperature differences,” they conclude, establishing HEOM as a powerful tool for describing charge transport in these and related superconducting nanostructures.

Non-Markovian Transport Limits in Hybrid Nanostructures

The calculations reveal that HEOM successfully predicts measured currents under these conditions, validating its utility in analyzing these hybrid nanostructures. Beyond simply matching experimental data, the framework accounts for the interplay of multiple physical effects within the Cooper pair splitter. This capability is particularly important given that recent experiments have increasingly focused on regimes where these non-Markovian effects are prominent, pushing the limits of traditional theoretical tools.

The method’s versatility extends to predicting the behavior of the system as an applied voltage is increased, at which point the HEOM results converge with analytical solutions derived from Markovian Lindblad master equations. The ability to model both charge and energy transport simultaneously highlights the power of the method for investigating these hybrid devices. The resonance positions observed in the current-voltage characteristics remain consistent with the conditions necessary for elastic cotunneling and Cooper pair splitting, even when accounting for finite bandwidth effects.

This finding provides valuable insight into the behavior of these devices and helps to refine the understanding of how different parameters influence their performance. The team also envisions applying the method to more complex systems, including coupled Cooper pair splitters and short Kitaev chains, to investigate the emergence of topological superconductivity and Majorana-like bound states. The open availability of the data and codes used in this study further encourages broader exploration of nonequilibrium transport phenomena in interacting superconducting nanostructures.

👉 More information
🗞 Quantum transport in Cooper pair splitters using hierarchical equations of motion
✍️ Riya Baruah, Neill Lambert, Franco Nori and Christian Flindt
🧠 DOI: http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/tdlt-y9pd

Stay current

See today’s quantum computing news on Quantum Zeitgeist for the latest breakthroughs in qubits, hardware, algorithms, and industry deals.

Avatar of Ivy Delaney

Ivy Delaney

Ivy Delaney has been working with neural networks and machine learning since the mid-nineties, back when a couple of hidden layers and a long afternoon of training counted as ambitious. She has watched the field go from academic curiosity to the thing quietly running underneath everything, and she brings that long view to quantum computing. For Quantum Zeitgeist she covers the ground where the two fields meet. That means quantum machine learning and the variational algorithms it leans on, and it also means the less glamorous but more interesting story of classical machine learning already doing real work inside quantum machines, decoding error-correcting codes, calibrating noisy hardware and learning the error models that simulators depend on. She writes about the hardware those algorithms have to run on too, and about the post-quantum cryptography scramble that the same hardware has set off. Her stories typically start with the paper, whether that is peer-reviewed work, conference proceedings or an arXiv preprint, with the source linked so you can hold a claim up against the research it came from. She is unimpressed by benchmarks that will not say what they beat, and by demonstrations that only work in the press release.

Latest Posts by Ivy Delaney: