Long-range entanglement survives noise in a model quantum system

Leonardo Lessa and colleagues at the Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics and collaborating institutions have established a direct link between higher-form anomalies and long-range entanglement in quantum materials. The researchers defined equivalence classes of long-range entanglement using stochastic local channels, effectively isolating purely quantum connections by removing classical correlations.

This work demonstrates that strong symmetries and their anomalies are inherent properties of an entire phase of matter, proving that anomalous states in (2+1)-D exhibit long-range bipartite entanglement and establishing a lower bound for their topological entanglement of formation. The team applied this formalism to the toric code under various noise conditions, including Pauli-X and Z dephasing, as well as ZX decoherence.

Higher-Form Anomalies Reveal Long-Range Entanglement in Mixed States

Researchers directly connected anomalies of higher-form symmetries to long-range entanglement present in any mixed quantum state exhibiting those symmetries, a finding that refines understanding of topologically ordered matter. This work establishes that even with local disturbances, quantum connections can persist, challenging previous assumptions about the fragility of entanglement in complex systems.

This novel approach allows for the differentiation of phases of matter based solely on quantum entanglement, offering a new tool for materials characterization. A key element of the investigation involved defining anomalies of one-form symmetries in (2+1)-D systems through local operatorial relations that demonstrate braiding and particle exchange, a process important for understanding topological order.

The study demonstrates that the presence of an anomaly, nontrivial braiding and self-statistics, directly implies long-range bipartite entanglement, establishing a fundamental link between symmetry and quantum correlation. The research provides a lower bound for the topological entanglement of formation, a mixed-state generalization of topological entanglement entropy, offering a quantifiable measure of entanglement strength.

These simulations revealed how the toric code can function as either a quantum or classical memory, depending on the type of noise encountered. “In open quantum systems, we directly relate anomalies of higher-form symmetries to the long-range entanglement of any mixed state with such symmetries,” the authors state in their published work.

The team also proposes a connection between higher-form anomalies and long-range multipartite entanglement in higher-dimensional mixed states, suggesting a broader applicability of their findings. This research, led by Leonardo A. Lessa, Shengqi Sang, Tsung-Cheng Lu, Timothy H. This procedure allows for the “dressing” of symmetries from an output state, after applying a stochastic local channel, onto the input state, all while preserving the anomaly relation. This technique offers a new way to analyze how symmetries behave under transformations and could be instrumental in designing more robust quantum systems capable of maintaining entanglement in noisy environments.

Stochastic Local Channels Define Equivalence Classes of Mixed-State Entanglement

Stochastic local channels (SLCs) provide a method for defining equivalence classes of mixed-state entanglement by effectively eliminating classical correlations, allowing researchers to isolate purely quantum connections within a material’s state. These channels, constructed as convex combinations of finite-depth local channels, cannot create long-range entanglement themselves, but are a tool to distinguish phases of matter based on differences in these quantum correlations. This approach builds on established techniques using finite-depth local channels and evolutions under local Lindbladians, extending the definition of mixed-state phases beyond purely gapped ground states.

The introduction of SLCs allows for the establishment of an equivalence relation between mixed states, determining if they are connected via these channels. This process defines equivalence classes characterized by patterns of long-range correlation, a concept increasingly used to define phases of matter in the literature.

Unlike previous methods, this formalism allows for the inclusion of long-range classical correlations, providing a more detailed understanding of entanglement in complex systems. A mixed state ρ and σ are considered equivalent if they can be converted into each other using these local channels. Strong symmetries within a mixed state, and any anomalies they exhibit, such as non-trivial braiding and self-statistics, are not merely mathematical curiosities but intrinsic features of the entire phase of matter.

The team’s work complements recent findings, strengthening the assertion of the value of topological entanglement formation for the toric code under both Pauli-Z and Pauli-X dephasing, regardless of the noise strength. Analysis reveals that the two-point correlation function of a specific state decays algebraically with distance, indicating long-range tripartite entanglement. The definition of long-range entanglement relies on identifying operations that create only short-range entanglement, such as finite-time evolutions under local Hamiltonians and their discrete counterparts.

The development of this framework opens avenues for further investigation into the fundamental properties of quantum phases of matter and the role of symmetry in defining them. The ability to effectively isolate quantum correlations through SLCs promises to refine their understanding of entanglement in complex quantum systems.

Symmetry Pullback Procedure Preserves Anomaly Relations

The ability to map symmetries between quantum states, a “symmetry pullback” procedure, preserves anomaly relations, a finding that bolsters understanding of how quantum phases of matter maintain their distinct characteristics even under disturbance. The team demonstrated this preservation using a mathematical framework that links anomalies, manifest as non-trivial braiding and self-statistics, to long-range entanglement within any mixed state exhibiting those symmetries. However, stochastic local channels (SLCs) can also introduce long-range classical correlations, leading to a need to define a “trivial” phase consisting of mixtures of short-range entangled states.

The researchers addressed this by proving that the anomaly of one-form symmetries in a specific topological order remains invariant under the symmetry pullback process, and that states in (2+1)-D with anomalous strong 1-form symmetries exhibit long-range bipartite entanglement. This establishes a firm connection between symmetry preservation and the inherent quantum properties of the system.

A key result detailed in the work is Lemma 2, formally outlining the symmetry pullback mechanism. This detailed analysis reinforces the idea that anomalies are not merely mathematical curiosities, but directly linked to observable quantum properties and the long-range entanglement that characterizes these phases of matter.

Long-Range Entanglement in (2+1)-D Systems with 1-Form Symmetries

This finding directly links abstract symmetry anomalies to concrete, measurable quantum properties within a material’s state, moving beyond purely mathematical descriptions. The resulting ZX decohered toric code exhibits long-range bipartite entanglement, supporting the broader conjecture that this phenomenon generalizes across systems with deconfined fermions. A general procedure of symmetry pullback for strong symmetries is introduced, whereby symmetries of the output state of an SLC are dressed into symmetries of the input state, with their anomaly relation preserved.

Topological Entanglement Formation Lower Bound for Mixed States

This measure, analogous to the entanglement of formation used for mixed-state entanglement, allows researchers to diagnose long-range quantum correlations by minimizing the averaged entanglement entropy across all possible decompositions of a given state. The approach builds on established work demonstrating a similar relationship for the topological entanglement entropy of pure states, offering a pathway to quantify entanglement even when quantum information is degraded. The team established this lower bound by using the braiding of strong one-form symmetries, a property related to how particles are exchanged and their associated statistics.

This connection suggests that the presence of these symmetries isn’t merely a mathematical curiosity, but a fundamental feature influencing observable quantum properties within a material. Specifically, the analysis demonstrates that in (2+1)-D systems, anomalous strong 1-form symmetries directly imply long-range bipartite entanglement, a key ingredient for robust quantum computation and communication. Their work reveals how these noise types impact the ability of the system to function as a quantum or classical memory, with the topological entanglement of formation serving as a diagnostic tool.

Intrinsically Mixed-State Topological Order (imTO) Discovery

The toric code, a prominent model for quantum computation, can exhibit a novel phase of matter even when subjected to specific types of noise, researchers have found. This recently discovered intrinsically mixed-state topological order arises under ZX decoherence, a particular form of quantum degradation, and lacks a corresponding pure-state counterpart. This work provides a complete characterization of topological order intrinsic to a mixed quantum state.

This analysis demonstrates that these systems exhibit long-range bipartite entanglement, a key indicator of quantum connections extending across macroscopic distances. The researchers used a symmetry pullback procedure, allowing them to trace symmetries through transformations while preserving their anomaly relations, a technique essential for understanding how symmetries behave in complex quantum systems. Understanding how entanglement persists in the face of noise is essential for developing quantum devices that can maintain coherence and perform reliable computations.

Connection Between Anomalies and Multipartite Entanglement in Higher Dimensions

This connection potentially applies to systems in higher dimensions, suggesting a fundamental relationship between symmetry anomalies and the complex correlations within quantum materials. The analysis reveals that the toric code, subjected to Pauli-X and Z dephasing noise, exhibits a refined phase diagram, separating distinct phases of long-range entanglement. Specifically, the team found that the topological entanglement of formation remains at log 2 throughout the long-range entanglement phase, even under noise, indicating a robustness to certain types of disturbances.

👉 More information
🗞 Higher-form anomaly and long-range entanglement of mixed states
✍️ Leonardo A. Lessa, Shengqi Sang, Tsung-Cheng Lu, Timothy H. Hsieh and Chong Wang
🧠 DOI: http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/cgcs-nx18

Stay current

See today’s quantum computing news on Quantum Zeitgeist for the latest breakthroughs in qubits, hardware, algorithms, and industry deals.

Avatar of Rusty Flint

Rusty Flint

Rusty is a quantum science nerd. He's been into academic science all his life, but spent his formative years doing less academic things. Now he turns his attention to write about his passion, the quantum realm. He loves all things Quantum Physics especially. Rusty likes the more esoteric side of Quantum Computing and the Quantum world. Everything from Quantum Entanglement to Quantum Physics. Rusty thinks that we are in the 1950s quantum equivalent of the classical computing world. While other quantum journalists focus on IBM's latest chip or which startup just raised $50 million, Rusty's over here writing 3,000-word deep dives on whether quantum entanglement might explain why you sometimes think about someone right before they text you. (Spoiler: it doesn't, but the exploration is fascinating)

Latest Posts by Rusty Flint: