Researchers at the Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt have demonstrated a new method for quantitatively measuring microwave power at millikelvin temperatures using superconducting qubits. The work centers on a circuit design featuring three transmon qubits directly coupled to a microwave feedline alongside another three qubits coupled dispersively via readout resonators, enabling a comparison of two distinct sensing approaches on a single device.
By combining these coupling schemes, the team achieved power sensing ranging from to for directly coupled qubits and from to for dispersively coupled qubits. The results, they state, constitute “the first step towards validation of qubit power sensing in dilution fridges, leading towards traceability for cryogenic microwave measurements.”
Transmon Qubit Design for Millikelvin Microwave Sensing
Microwave power measurements ranging from to were enabled by the design of a superconducting circuit, achieved through direct coupling of transmon qubits to a feedline. The researchers specifically designed the circuit to facilitate this direct comparison, focusing on the reliability of each coupling scheme for quantitative microwave power sensing at extremely low temperatures. Directly coupled qubits determine the dipole moment through the qubit relaxation rate, a parameter readily measured, but are limited to the fW range for accessible microwave power.
Dispersive coupling, however, uses the AC Stark shift, allowing for sensing even with fixed-frequency qubits by operating off-resonance with the qubit itself. Both sensing methods yield the power at the microwave feedline, referencing all measurements to the same point at room temperature. By combining dispersively coupled and directly coupled qubits on the same device, the researchers are able to explore different power ranges: from to for the directly coupled qubits and from to for the dispersively coupled qubits.
Directly-Coupled Qubits Measure fW Microwave Power Ranges
The directly coupled transmon qubits in this study demonstrate a measurable power range extending from to, a sensitivity achieved through the relationship between microwave amplitude and the resulting Rabi frequency of the two-level system. This range contrasts with the dispersively coupled qubits on the same device, which access a different portion of the microwave spectrum for sensing. This common reference is critical for validating the accuracy of each approach and identifying potential discrepancies stemming from the measurement setup itself.
This tunability allows researchers to tailor the qubit’s response to specific microwave frequencies, potentially optimizing sensitivity for different applications. This observation emphasises the importance of careful calibration and signal conditioning at higher frequencies to minimize measurement errors. “This assessment already suggests that the dispersively coupled qubits are less suitable for microwave power measurements than the directly coupled qubits,” the researchers state, highlighting a key distinction between the two approaches.
Dispersive Coupling Enables Broad Frequency Power Sensing
Dispersive coupling, while presenting challenges to measurement accuracy, allows for power sensing across a wider range than direct coupling alone; comprehensive simulations are currently needed to determine absolute values across a broad frequency range. The team’s circuit design incorporates both directly coupled and dispersively coupled transmon qubits on a single device, enabling a comparative assessment of these two distinct sensing methods and their respective limitations.
Specifically, the high-power qubits, coupled dispersively via λ/4 coplanar-waveguide resonators, exhibit a coupling quality factor, , ranging from 2000 to 3000 and a resonator-qubit coupling capacitance, , of approximately 0.05 picofarads. This expanded range is important because the uncertainty associated with the transfer function between the qubit and the feedline currently limits the overall accuracy of dispersive coupling, exceeding the uncertainty observed with directly coupled qubits.
The relationship between incident electric field amplitude and the Rabi frequency of a two-level system forms the basis of this quantitative sensing approach, linking the incident power at the feedline, , to the Rabi frequency through the equation = (ℏω_q). Further experimental data, gathered at the qubits’ sweet spot, is detailed in the supplementary materials, providing a more complete picture of the system’s performance.
The team’s work represents a first step toward establishing traceability of microwave measurements in cryogenic environments, a critical need for advancing quantum technologies and ensuring reliable measurements. The distinction between low-power and high-power qubits is defined by their effective power sensing ranges, allowing for optimized performance across different signal levels.
Microwave Attenuation Measurement & Uncertainty Estimation
Microwave line attenuation measurements, important for calibrating cryogenic experiments, yielded best estimates of and for directly and dispersively coupled transmons, respectively, when determining attenuation from room temperature to millikelvin stages. These values represent the degree to which microwave signals weaken as they travel through the system, a parameter essential for accurate power quantification at extremely low temperatures. The team’s modeling included detailed uncertainty estimations derived from repeated measurements, allowing for a robust assessment of each sensing method’s reliability.
This expanded range is a direct result of the circuit’s design, which incorporates both coupling schemes on a single device, facilitating a comparative analysis of their respective strengths and limitations. The simpler circuit of the directly coupled qubits yielded lower uncertainties, making them more reliable for power sensing, while the dispersive coupling method presents challenges in accurately determining the qubit-to-feedline transfer function.
The larger uncertainty observed in the dispersively coupled qubit measurements, likely stemming from the complexity of the additional coupling resonator, highlights a key obstacle to achieving high accuracy. The researchers state, identifying this as the main bottleneck for accurate power sensing. To quantify microwave power at the feedline, the team fitted experimental data to an equation defining = , where denotes the output power of the instrument at room temperature and represents the attenuation of the microwave line.
The resulting fit, with as the sole fitting parameter, allowed for a comparison of the power at room temperature and at the millikelvin stage. However, the team acknowledges that considerably more work is required to establish full traceability for cryogenic microwave measurements, particularly due to the uncertainties associated with the dispersively coupled qubits.
Simulations and data suggest that the reduced line attenuation obtained with the dispersively coupled qubits at compared to is unrealistic, further reinforcing the challenges of accurately modeling the system. “We believe such traceable measurement techniques will prove to be important for further developments in cryogenic quantum technologies,” the researchers conclude, emphasizing the potential impact of their findings on the field. The team’s analysis points to the need for improved modeling techniques and circuit designs to minimize uncertainties and enhance the accuracy of power sensing in future cryogenic quantum systems.
Towards Traceable Cryogenic Microwave Measurements with Qubits
The team’s analysis indicates that accurately determining the qubit-to-feedline transfer function, essential for absolute power determination, presents a significant challenge, particularly across a broad frequency range. Direct comparisons between directly and dispersively coupled qubits were enabled by a single device incorporating three transmon qubits of each type, allowing for simultaneous assessment of both coupling schemes.
Simulations and experimental data suggest that the increased circuit complexity inherent in dispersive coupling hinders accurate estimation of the qubit-feedline transfer function, currently representing the main bottleneck for achieving precise power sensing. Additional experimental results at were also collected and are detailed in the supplementary materials, further supporting the comparative analysis of the two coupling schemes.
The team’s work builds on earlier quantum techniques for cryogenic microwave measurements, which often rely on superconducting qubits referencing the Rabi frequency to the incident electric field and the qubit’s dipole moment. While previous studies used flux qubits directly coupled to microwave transmission lines, this research focuses on a comparative analysis of direct and dispersive coupling methods within a single integrated circuit. Despite these adjustments, the inherent difficulties in accurately characterizing the transfer function of the dispersively coupled qubits remain a primary obstacle to achieving the desired level of traceability.
👉 More information
🗞 Quantitative measurement of microwave power at millikelvin temperatures: Comparison between dispersively and directly coupled superconducting qubits
✍️ Asen L. Georgiev, Christoph Kissling, Fabian Kaap, Victor Gaydamachenko, Lukas Grünhaupt and Mark Bieler
🧠 ArXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.21397v1




See today’s quantum computing news on Quantum Zeitgeist for the latest breakthroughs in qubits, hardware, algorithms, and industry deals.
