Entropies represent fundamental measures of uncertainty, crucial to statistics and quantitative sciences. Roberto Rubboli, Erkka Haapasalo, and Marco Tomamichel, from the National University of Singapore and the University of Copenhagen, have now delivered a complete characterisation of conditional entropies, addressing a long-standing open problem in the field. Despite the existence of several definitions, a fully axiomatic understanding of conditional entropy, quantifying uncertainty given correlated information, has remained elusive until now. This research establishes that the most general form of conditional entropy is defined by exponential averages of Rényi entropies, parameterised by a real number and a probability measure.
The research establishes that the most general form of conditional entropy is captured by a family of measures which are exponential averages of Rényi entropies of the conditioned distribution, parameterized by a real parameter and a probability measure on the positive reals.
This breakthrough resolves a long-standing challenge in defining conditional entropy through a consistent set of operational axioms. The team proved this by defining conditional entropy through additivity for independent random variables, invariance under relabeling, and monotonicity under conditional mixing channels, axioms essential for any operationally meaningful definition.
The study unveils a mathematical framework for understanding uncertainty in scenarios where observers have access to potentially correlated side information. Researchers began by examining the family of Rényi entropies, parameterized by a real number α, and extended this concept to the conditional realm.
They rigorously demonstrated that any measure of conditional entropy satisfying their defined axioms can be expressed as an integral of Rényi entropies, weighted by a probability measure. This provides a comprehensive and unified description of conditional entropy, moving beyond previously fragmented definitions.
This work establishes that these newly characterised quantities determine the rate of transformation under conditional mixing. Furthermore, the research provides a set of second laws of thermodynamics with side information, specifically for states diagonal in the energy eigenbasis. The findings have significant implications for diverse fields, including cryptography, data compression, and quantum thermodynamics.
By providing a complete axiomatic characterization, the study opens avenues for developing more robust and efficient information processing techniques and a deeper understanding of uncertainty in complex systems. Experiments show that the derived conditional entropies are not merely theoretical constructs but have concrete operational significance.
The team demonstrated their applicability by showing how these measures govern the limits of information transformation under specific conditions. This connection to practical limits solidifies the importance of the research and highlights its potential for real-world applications. The research also provides a foundation for exploring new thermodynamic laws that account for the presence of side information, potentially leading to advancements in energy efficiency and quantum technologies.
Axiomatic characterisation via additivity, invariance and monotonic conditional mixing channels yields unique quantum representations
Scientists investigated conditional entropy, a measure of uncertainty crucial across quantitative sciences, by establishing a complete axiomatic characterization of this concept. The research team focused on defining conditional entropy through additivity for independent random variables, invariance under relabeling, and monotonicity under conditional mixing channels.
To achieve this, they demonstrated that the most general form of conditional entropy is captured by a family of measures which are exponential averages of Rényi entropies, parameterized by a real parameter and a probability measure on the positive reals. The study pioneered a novel approach by establishing sufficient conditions for transforming one joint probability distribution into another using conditionally mixing channels, leveraging arguments from preordered semirings developed in prior work.
Researchers constructed a specific semiring where conditional entropies arise as relevant functions, enabling the determination of extremal conditional entropies. Experiments employed the general results on preordered semirings, specifically those detailed in references [16, 17], to derive these conditions and characterise the general form of entropies as convex combinations of Rényi entropies.
Scientists rigorously analysed the parameters governing conditional entropies, determining the necessary and sufficient conditions for satisfying the defined axioms. This involved examining large-sample behaviour and catalytic results, forming the basis for applications to rates and the second laws of quantum thermodynamics with side information.
The team proved that the general form of conditional entropies are indeed convex combinations of the extremal entropies, demonstrating a fundamental connection to Rényi entropies. Formal definitions were introduced to underpin the manuscript’s arguments, including definitions of embedding, relabeling, and doubly stochastic channels.
Researchers defined majorization, establishing that PX majorizes QX′ if probability distributions can be related through embedding, relabeling, and a doubly stochastic map. Lemma 2.5 detailed the initial sum condition, stating that PX ⪰QX if and only if the partial sums of the non-increasingly ordered components of PX are greater than or equal to those of QX for all k from 1 to d-1, with equality holding for k=d. The study defined entropy, requiring invariance under relabeling, monotonicity under mixing channels, additivity, and normalization, establishing a robust framework for quantifying uncertainty.
Axiomatic derivation of conditional entropy reveals exponential Rényi averages and thermodynamic connections between information and energy
Scientists have achieved a complete characterization of conditional entropy, a fundamental measure of uncertainty in information theory, through a rigorous axiomatic approach. The research demonstrates that the most general form of conditional entropy is captured by a family of measures which are exponential averages of Rényi entropies, parameterized by a real parameter and a probability measure on the positive reals.
Experiments revealed that these quantities precisely determine the rate of transformation under conditional mixing channels, establishing a crucial link between information theory and thermodynamics. The team measured and proved that these newly defined conditional entropies satisfy essential axioms for operationally meaningful definitions, including additivity for independent random variables, invariance under relabeling, and monotonicity under conditional mixing channels.
Results demonstrate that the derived family of measures accurately reflects uncertainty from the viewpoint of an observer with access to correlated side information. Data shows that the work builds upon the established framework of Rényi entropies, extending their applicability to scenarios involving conditional probabilities and side information.
Measurements confirm that the established second laws of quantum thermodynamics hold true for states diagonal in the energy eigenbasis, utilizing the derived conditional entropies with side information. The breakthrough delivers a comprehensive understanding of how uncertainty is quantified when considering correlated systems, offering a powerful tool for analyzing information processing tasks.
Tests prove that the parameters governing these conditional entropies are constrained by necessary conditions derived through detailed mathematical analysis, ensuring the consistency and validity of the framework. Specifically, the research establishes that any quantity satisfying the defined axioms can be expressed as an integral of Rényi entropies, weighted by a probability measure.
Scientists recorded that this integral representation provides a flexible and general way to define conditional entropy, encompassing previously proposed definitions as special cases. The study’s findings have implications for understanding the limits of data compression, cryptography, and the fundamental laws governing energy transformation in quantum systems.
Axiomatic characterisation reveals Rényi entropy families define conditional entropy measures
Scientists have established a complete characterization of conditional entropy through a set of essential axioms: additivity for independent random variables, invariance under relabeling, and monotonicity under conditional mixing channels. This work demonstrates that the most general form of conditional entropy is captured by a family of measures which are exponential averages of Rényi entropies, parameterized by a real number and a probability measure on the positive reals.
The significance of these findings lies in providing a fundamental understanding of uncertainty quantification, extending beyond existing definitions and offering a robust framework for information-theoretic analysis. These newly defined quantities determine the rate of transformation under conditional mixing, and establish second laws of thermodynamics applicable to states diagonal in the energy eigenbasis.
The authors acknowledge a limitation in that their characterization relies on specific axioms, and the applicability of these axioms may vary depending on the context. Future research could explore the implications of this generalized conditional entropy in diverse fields such as cryptography and statistical physics.
Further investigation into the properties of the parameter space and the associated probability measures could also refine the understanding of conditional entropy and its operational meaning. This research offers a solid foundation for advancing the theoretical understanding of uncertainty and its role in quantitative sciences.
👉 More information
🗞 A complete characterisation of conditional entropies
🧠 ArXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601.23213
