Conservation of Quantum Chromodynamics Confirmed, Refuting Claims of Violation in arXiv:2510.18951

The longstanding question of charge conservation in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) receives further clarification from Wen-Yuan Ai, Björn Garbrecht from Technische Universität München, and Carlos Tamarit from Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz, et al. This team directly addresses a recent critique concerning their previously established demonstrations of charge conservation, rooted in careful treatments of both path integral and canonical quantization. They demonstrate that arguments suggesting a violation of charge conservation, based on analogies with a rotor system and analyses of low-energy effective theories, are flawed. Specifically, the researchers show these arguments rely on unphysical assumptions and fail to account for the full range of allowed couplings, thereby reinforcing the validity of established theoretical frameworks and deepening our understanding of fundamental particle interactions.

Solving the Strong CP Problem with Topology

The strong CP problem concerns the puzzling absence of CP violation, a symmetry relating particles and their mirror images, in the strong nuclear force. The Standard Model allows for a term that should cause this violation, but experiments show no evidence of it. This research presents a novel approach, focusing on the mathematical order of calculations and how topological effects, complex configurations within the strong force, are treated. The team argues that standard calculations incorrectly assume the order of taking limits is interchangeable, specifically calculating the effects of infinite spacetime volume before considering all possible topological configurations.

They propose that correctly accounting for the order of these limits, and the finite size of space at a fundamental level, can resolve the strong CP problem without invoking new physics like axions. This is achieved through a novel theoretical framework involving a ‘subvolume’ of space, where calculations demonstrate the cancellation of CP-violating phases. The researchers connect this subvolume approach to the ‘t Hooft vertex, a well-established topological object in quantum chromodynamics, further solidifying their argument. This method involves an effective theory defined within this subvolume, allowing for explicit demonstration of CP phase cancellation through integrating out fluctuations in the remaining volume. The research suggests that the strong CP problem may be a consequence of how calculations are performed, rather than a fundamental flaw in the theory itself, highlighting the importance of carefully considering the mathematical order of calculations in quantum field theory.

Rotor Model Confirms Infinite Volume Consistency

Researchers have rigorously demonstrated the consistency of quantum chromodynamics (QCD) with infinite spacetime volumes, addressing critiques suggesting inconsistencies arise at large scales. Building upon previous work establishing CP conservation through both path integral methods and canonical quantization, the team employed a rotor model, a simplified analogue for QCD, to investigate the topological susceptibility, a key quantity related to CP violation. Their calculations reveal that the topological susceptibility does not vanish at infinite volumes, contradicting claims made elsewhere. This was achieved by calculating the topological charge density and its correlation function, demonstrating its direct connection to the fundamental rules governing quantum mechanics, known as canonical commutation relations.

The team also analyzed the effective chiral Lagrangian, a low-energy approximation of QCD, showing that claims of CP violation rely on restricting the allowed forms of interactions. They demonstrated that both options, infinite volume before or after considering topological sectors, are consistent with well-defined calculations derived from the underlying theory. This detailed analysis, coupled with the rotor model calculations, provides strong evidence supporting the original conclusions of CP conservation in quantum chromodynamics and refuting the critique, reinforcing the understanding of the strong force.

Charge Conservation Confirmed in Quantum Chromodynamics

Scientists have rigorously confirmed the conservation of CP symmetry within the strong interactions of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), directly addressing recent critiques. Through detailed analysis of both path integral methods and canonical quantization techniques, the team demonstrates that previous results remain valid, resolving apparent contradictions. They investigated claims that a vanishing topological susceptibility, observed in a quantum rotor model, would contradict the observed mass of the η’ meson, a key indicator of CP violation. However, their calculations reveal that the topological susceptibility does not vanish, even when considering infinite spatial volumes, because it is fundamentally determined by the rules governing quantum mechanics, independent of the order in which calculations are performed.

Further analysis focused on the low-energy effective theory of chiral Lagrangians, where arguments suggested CP violation could be established. The team demonstrated that these arguments rely on specific choices of interactions that do not represent the most general form allowed by theoretical considerations. By adhering to the full range of allowed interactions, consistent with calculations derived from the underlying theory, the team showed that CP conservation remains consistent. Specifically, calculations of the topological susceptibility for the rotor model yielded a value independent of the integration volume, thus confirming consistency with the observed η’ meson mass, solidifying the understanding of CP symmetry in quantum chromodynamics. The authors acknowledge that their findings depend on the specific framework of canonical quantization and the treatment of gauge transformations.